Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2: Hallmark’s Holiday Reality Show is Back and It’s So Much Fun

Hallmark Channel is decking the halls with more unscripted chaos (the good kind) as Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 returns – and yes, we’re already emotionally invested.

Season 1 delivered snowball fights, surprise tears, and enough Hallmark-worthy moments to fill three ornament bins. Now it’s back with even more festive challenges, dramatic monologues, and familiar Hallmark faces dropping in to help crown the next leading man. It’s part talent show, part emotional bootcamp, and somehow still manages to make us cry and cackle in the same episode.

Bookmark this post – we’ll update it weekly with new episode recaps, guest judge appearances, and anything else the snow globe shakes loose.

What Is Finding Mr. Christmas?

Glad you asked. Finding Mr. Christmas is Hallmark Channel’s original unscripted competition series where ten aspiring actors battle it out – festively, of course – for the ultimate prize: a starring role in a future Hallmark Christmas movie. Yes, it’s real. Yes, we’re obsessed.

Each week brings two challenges:

Festive Face-Off – Picture blindfolded snowman building, holiday trivia, or a full-blown runway of questionable Christmas sweaters.

Star Quality Challenge – This is where the guys swap elf hats for scripts and try to channel their inner Andrew Walker in front of a panel of judges.

This isn’t about backstabbing or dramatic exits (although we do love a good elimination cave). It’s about charm, charisma, and who can convincingly fall in love while decorating a tree in flannel.

Hosted and co-created by Hallmark MVP Jonathan Bennett, the show mixes heartfelt pep talks with holiday chaos in a way that somehow works. Like, really works.

When Does Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 Premiere?

While Hallmark’s still keeping the exact premiere date wrapped tighter than a last-minute gift, we do know this: Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 will air Monday nights this fall on Hallmark Channel, sliding into the Countdown to Christmas lineup like it owns the sled.

ICYMI, Season 1 was a Hallmark+ exclusive – but with the network rethinking its streaming strategy, Season 2 is stepping into the primetime spotlight. Translation? No app required, just your remote and maybe a mug of peppermint cocoa.

Who’s Hosting and Judging Finding Mr. Christmas?

Jonathan Bennett (Host & Lead Judge)

Jonathan Bennett is back as host, co-creator, executive producer, motivational speaker, resident pun master – honestly, is there anything he doesn’t do on this show? Finding Mr. Christmas is his brainchild, and it shows. He brings big brother energy with just enough Hallmark sparkle, always rooting for these guys like they’re one heartfelt monologue away from greatness. Whether he’s delivering a tearful pep talk or launching into a surprise holiday challenge, JB is the heart (and chaos coordinator) of this snow-dusted journey.

Melissa Peterman (Lead Judge & Queen of Our Hearts)

And then there’s Melissa Peterman, the unscripted queen we never knew Hallmark needed. She’s back in the judge’s chair with razor-sharp wit, years of comedic timing, and exactly zero patience for mediocrity in a flannel shirt. Melissa can spot a future Hallmark lead from across the soundstage and she’s not afraid to call it like she sees it.

Also? Her completely unfiltered objectification of the contestants is honestly one of our favorite parts of the show. From calling out biceps to commenting on their smolder, Peterman delivers it with the kind of confidence and comic timing that has us howling. She’s bold, fabulous, and somehow makes judging feel like a holiday party we desperately want an invite to.

Who’s Judging the Holiday Hustle?

This season’s guest judge lineup is basically a Hallmark dream board come to life. Each week, a new familiar face pops in to size up the competition, drop some wisdom, and remind us all what it takes to carry a movie while wearing mittens and making eye contact over cocoa.

Confirmed guest judges include:

• Janel Parrish
• Alison Sweeney
• Erin Krakow
• Heather Hemmens
• Hunter King
• Ashley Williams
• Sharon Lawrence

And because Hallmark never misses a chance for a festive surprise, superfans Gail and Alicia – yes, the lucky duo who rode ATVs with Tyler Hynes in Christmas at Sea (we’re not jealous, you are) – are popping in as special guest judges this season.

What Does the Winner Get?

At the end of this eight-episode sleigh ride, one lucky contestant will walk away with the ultimate prize: a role in an actual Hallmark Channel Christmas movie. Yes, really. This is not a drill.

Need proof it’s legit? Last season’s winner, Ezra Moreland, went from Navy rescue diver and part-time model to starring opposite Jessica Lowndes in Happy Howlidays. So yeah – dreams come true. No pressure, Season 2 guys… but the bar is basically wrapped, bowed, and already on set.

Where Can You Watch Finding Mr. Christmas?

• Season 2 will air Monday nights this fall on Hallmark Channel.
• Season 1 is available now on Hallmark+ 

Finding Mr. Christmas Episode Recaps – Season 2

We’re recapping every single episode on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast – because obviously we have thoughts, strong opinions, and an alarming emotional attachment to this show.

New links drop weekly, so check back in between your rewatches and replays of JB’s pep talks.

Why You Should Watch

Look, we get it – Hallmark fans aren’t exactly lining up to welcome reality TV into their perfectly lit, small-town Christmas universes. But Finding Mr. Christmas? It’s different. It’s the warmest, weirdest, most unexpectedly wonderful twist on holiday storytelling we didn’t know we needed.

Yes, it’s unscripted. No, it doesn’t ruin the magic. If anything, it celebrates it – one snowman obstacle course and teary audition at a time. Watching these guys pour their hearts into becoming the next Hallmark leading man is surprisingly emotional, low-key hilarious, and way more addicting than we care to admit.

This show isn’t just festive fluff – it’s full-on flannel-wrapped ambition. And we are all the way in.

We’re Your New Hallmark Besties

Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!

Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!

Subscribe today!

’