Will There Ever Be a Sequel to Family History Mysteries?
The 2023 Hallmark movie Family History Mysteries: Buried Secrets captivated audiences with its intriguing blend of genealogy and suspense, leaving fans digging for more. Today we’re going to unravel the question: will there ever be a sequel to Family History Mysteries?

Listen to the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast review of Family History Mysteries: Buried Secrets
A Gripping Storyline with Niall Matter and Janel Parrish
Starring Janel Parrish as Sophie McClaren, a genealogist who unravels family mysteries, and Niall Matter as Jackson Ford, the twin brother of her close friend Jonathan (played by Morgan David Jones). With Jackson’s help, Sophie must use her skills to track down the brothers’ long-lost birth father – a man they never even knew existed – in time to save Jonathan’s life. Ultimately, growing closer to Jackson on this search gives Sophie the push to finally explore the mystery of her own adoption.
Writers Who Bring Drama and Mystery
The movie’s script, crafted by Brynn Bonner and Amber Benson, blended family drama with a gripping mystery. Amber Benson, known for her iconic role as Tara Maclay on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, has also made a name for herself in writing with works that veer into darker territories, including Oscar Pistorius: Blade Runner Killer and Terror in the Woods. Her unique blend of experience in both acting and writing adds a special touch to her projects.
Hallmark Director Jonathan Wright’s Expertise
Director Jonathan Wright, who brought Buried Secrets to life, has a strong track record with Hallmark, having directed True Justice: Family Ties and Jolly Good Christmas. Wright’s experience with Hallmark projects suggests he has a keen understanding of the network’s audience and its storytelling style.
Hints of a Sequel: What We Know
In a conversation with source close to the project, there was a hint that a sequel to Family History Mysteries: Buried Secrets might be in the works. While no official announcements have been made, the anticipation among fans is palpable.
Both Janel Parrish and Niall Matter have continued to make waves on the Hallmark Channel.
Parrish, known for her role on Pretty Little Liars, co-starred in Never Been Chris’d during last year’s Countdown to Christmas. She also appeared with Tyler Hynes in the Kansas City Chiefs football movie spoof Falling for Football.
Many have wondered why Parrish didn’t nab the lead role in the upcoming Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story. The actress recently shared that she underwent surgery for endometriosis after months of pain. Maybe she’s taking some well-deserved time off to heal?
Niall Matter, one of the network’s fan-favorites finished out 2023 with the smash hit Holiday Hotline, as well as a surprise cameo as DJ Ginger Jeff in The Santa Summit. We have yet to see Matter in a new film in 2024 but fingers are crossed for a starring role in an unannounced Countdown to Christmas movie.
Why Fans Are Eager for More Family History Mysteries
As fans eagerly await any official confirmation, the hope for a sequel to Family History Mysteries remains strong. With the film’s engaging premise, talented cast, and promising hints, a follow-up could be just around the corner. Stay tuned for updates on the potential sequel to Family History Mysteries: Buried Secrets as we keep our fingers crossed for more of Sophie McClaren’s compelling adventures!
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!
