When Will the Two Newest Curious Caterer Movies Premiere in 2025?
If you’ve been waiting (and waiting…) for Curious Caterer movies to premiere in 2025, you’re not alone – watching for updates has felt a lot like staring at a pot of water that refuses to boil. Fans of Goldy and Tom have been eager for a new mystery this year, but it’s officially been confirmed: no new Curious Caterer movies are slated to premiere in 2025. While that might feel like a recipe for disappointment, don’t hang up your apron just yet because we’ve got everything you need to stay sleuthing, including cast updates and our favorite picks to satisfy your cozy crime cravings in the meantime.
Updated: August 2025
Why There Are No Curious Caterer Premieres in 2025
While Hallmark never made an official statement about skipping a Curious Caterer release in 2025, we can only speculate as to why Goldy and Tom didn’t return this year. The truth is: new movies have been down across the board. Hallmark Media has been experiencing some serious growing pains – especially with ongoing executive shakeups and shifting content strategies. At the same time, the slow death of cable has left networks like Hallmark scrambling to keep longtime viewers engaged while also exploring more innovative storytelling
And while it’s easy (and frankly, kind of fun) to gripe about the lack of fresh mysteries and the noticeable absence of fan-favorite stars on our screens, we’re still feeling optimistic. Curious Caterer remains one of Hallmark’s most beloved mystery franchises, and based on everything we’ve heard from the stars themselves, it’s not over. Hallmark may be holding off for strategic reasons – but something tells us they know fans aren’t done with Goldy and Tom just yet.
What the Cast Said About Curious Caterer’s Future
Both Nikki DeLoach and Andrew Walker have addressed the future of Curious Caterer – and while no new movie aired in 2025, they’ve definitely hinted that Goldy and Tom’s story isn’t over. One even confirmed that more is in the works, though fans may need to be patient a little longer. We broke down exactly what they said (and what they didn’t) in this post, so if you’re ready to read between the lines, we’ve got the scoop.
Cast Updates
While Goldy and Tom are off the screen (for now), both Nikki DeLoach and Andrew Walker are still very much part of Hallmark’s 2025 Countdown to Christmas.
Nikki is starring in a nostalgic holiday movie set at the Grand Ole Opry alongside Kristoffer Polaha, complete with time travel, heartfelt reunions, and country music charm.
Andrew, meanwhile, is busier than ever. He’s reuniting with Lacey Chabert in She’s Making a List and reprising his fan-favorite role as one of the Brenner brothers in the third Three Wisest Men movie. So while there may not be a new Curious Caterer premiere this year, you can still catch your favorite stars spreading holiday cheer across the Hallmark schedule.
What to Watch While You Wait for Curious Caterer 2026
If you’re looking to scratch that cozy mystery itch while you wait for more Curious Caterer, Hallmark has a lineup of fan-favorite franchises that deliver all the twists, romance, and small-town sleuthing you love. Here are a few standout series to dive into next:
- Mistletoe Murders – This brand-new Hallmark mystery series stars Sarah Drew as a small-town shop owner whose holiday season takes a deadly turn. Blending Christmas charm with criminal intrigue, Mistletoe Murders is perfect for fans who like their festive lights tangled up with red herrings.
- Mystery 101 – One of Hallmark’s most beloved mystery franchises, Mystery 101 follows English professor Amy Winslow and Detective Travis Burke as they solve complex cases with brains, banter, and undeniable chemistry. With seven films (and a famously unresolved cliffhanger), this series has become a must-watch for mystery fans.
- Hannah Swensen Mysteries – Based on the bestselling books by Joanne Fluke, this long-running Hallmark Mystery series stars Alison Sweeney as Hannah, a baker with a talent for solving murders in her small town of Lake Eden. With sweet treats, cozy vibes, and a growing list of suspicious characters, Hannah Swensen Mysteries delivers classic whodunnit energy – often with a side of cookies.
- Mystery Island – When a getaway to a mystery-themed resort takes a deadly turn, a local detective joins forces with a vacationing British criminal psychiatrist to crack the case. With its tropical setting, clever twists, and sparks between the unlikely duo, this Hallmark mystery delivers both intrigue and escapism.
- Private Eyes – Streaming now on Hallmark+, this Canadian import stars Jason Priestley as ex-pro hockey player Matt Shade, who teams up with savvy private investigator Angie Everett (Cindy Sampson) to tackle cases across Toronto. Equal parts witty banter, slow-burn chemistry, and sharp detective work, Private Eyes has become a binge-worthy fan favorite for mystery lovers.
The Future of Hallmark Mystery Movies
The future of Hallmark mysteries has become a hot topic among fans, with some speculating – and even fearing – that the network might eventually phase out its beloved mystery programming. It’s true that the pace of new franchise releases has slowed in 2025, fueling concern.
But let’s not sound the alarm just yet. In fact, Hallmark introduced a slew of new mystery titles since 2024, including The Cases of Mystery Lane, Nelly Knows Mysteries, Tipline Mysteries, Family Practice Mysteries, CrimeTime, True Justice, and Haunted Harmony Mysteries. Some of these premieres were met with major fanfare and solid ratings, proving there’s still plenty of appetite for clever whodunits and cozy crime-solving. So, are Hallmark mysteries really disappearing? Based on this lineup, it looks like they’re just getting started.
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
