Who Will Win Finding Mr. Christmas?

Are you ready to tune in for Season 2 of Finding Mr. Christmas on Hallmark? This holiday-season reality competition is back and better than ever as ten charming guys vie for the title “Mr. Christmas” and the opportunity to become Hallmark’s next big male leading star.

Hey, we hear you – reality TV might not be your usual Hallmark go-to. But trust us, Finding Mr. Christmas is pure festive fun. Between the playful challenges, over-the-top holiday cheer, and unexpected emotional moments, you’ll be surprised by how quickly you start rooting for your favorite soon-to-be Hallmark hunk. It’s lighthearted, cozy, and just the right amount of chaotic – the perfect seasonal escape for even the most traditional Hallmark fan.

Updated October 21, 2025

The ten contestants of Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 | Hallmark Channel

Catch our Girls Gone Hallmark recap, where we spill the hot cocoa on our favorite Finding Mr. Christmas moments, share weekly predictions, and cheer (or laugh) our way through the competition!

What Will the Men Have to Do to Win Mr. Christmas?

To claim the title of Mr. Christmas, these men will have to tackle a range of festive challenges that test more than just their acting chops. From performing holiday-themed scenes and swoon-worthy kissing scenes to ice skating, dancing, and even a few physical competitions, they’ll need to embody all aspects of a Hallmark leading man.

Meet the Host & Judges of Finding Mr. Christmas

When it comes to judging, the pressure is no joke! Each week, the contestants must wow a panel of Hallmark experts and keep host Jonathan Bennett on their side. If they fall short, they may have to take their stocking and go home. Literally. They take their stocking down from the fireplace when they are eliminated.

Alongside host Jonathan Bennett, fan favorite Melissa Peterman returns and she’s a total scene-stealer. She serves looks, delivers pep talks, and says out loud everything we’re thinking at home. Each week, they’ll be joined by rotating guest judges who step in as scene partners and mentors for the contestants, offering firsthand advice on what it really takes to shine in a Hallmark movie. This season’s guest lineup is stacked with Hallmark royalty, including Janel Parrish, Heather Hemmens, Alison Sweeney, Hunter King, Ashley Williams, Sharon Lawrence, and Erin Krakow – talk about a Christmas casting dream team!

When & Where to Watch Finding Mr. Christmas

Premiere: Monday, October 27 at 8/7c on the Hallmark Channel.
Episodes will also be available next day on Hallmark+, making it easy to stay caught up even if you miss the live broadcast.
New episodes roll out weekly through early December, so mark your calendar for your weekly dose of holiday competition fun!

We’ll be covering every episode of Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 right here at Girls Gone Hallmark – sharing our signature mix of laughs, hot takes, and Hallmark cheer on the podcast, plus weekly written recaps so you can relive all the festive drama and behind-the-scenes magic with us.

Listen to Every Finding Mr. Christmas Season 1 Recap!

Did you miss the first season? Lucky for you, the entire season is ready to binge on Hallmark+. And you bet we recapped every single moment.

We’re Your New Hallmark Besties

Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!

Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!

Subscribe today!