Listener Mailbag: The One Where Our Listeners Outshine Us
Welcome back to Listener Mailbag, where the Girls Gone Hallmark inbox becomes a delightful grab bag of insider intel, cinematic corrections, heartfelt confessions, celebrity sightings, HR audits, sports smack talk, and Easter eggs we absolutely missed. This week our listeners take us from Buffalo stadium lore to Patriots-stat fact-checking, from Hallmark cruise casting tea to on-set freezing temperatures, from Australian swooning over Polaha to Newport HR violations, legal-drama endorsements, diner-based existential crises, and even a Simpsons reference hiding in plain sight. If you ever wondered what happens when the smartest, funniest Hallmark fans on earth email us… well, buckle up.
Try Magic Mind For Better Productivity
We took the Magic Mind Challenge for 7-days! Now, it’s your turn. Get 20% off Magic Mind Mental Performance shots and 48% off subscriptions. Use GIRLSGONE20 to snag that discount!
Visit : Magic Mind | Mental Performance Shot | Original
Want to be part of the next Listener Mailbag? Email [email protected]
Leave a voicemail: (949) 329-8090
Listen to this Week’s Listener Mailbag
Patti’s Buffalo Masterclass
Patti from Buffalo heard our Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story review and immediately gifted us a treasure trove of local insight: exact filming dates, perfectly miserable faux-December weather, and the confirmation that ice bikes are a thing. She also let us know that a real gave between the Bills and the Patriots was shown at the end of the movie. And finally, Patti shared Buffalo’s own iconic sponge candy, a regional specialty we can (and absolutely should) order online like responsible Hallmark researchers.
A Patriots Fan Enters the Chat
Patriots fan Paula stepped forward to let us know the game in the movie was real and they did use authentic footage. We appreciate both her sportsmanship and her willingness to fact-check us with receipts.
All Hail Mackie: Keeper of Details, Queen of Our Facebook Group
Mackie brings us a People.com nugget revealing that Rachel Boston and Brendan Penny pitched themselves as a duo on the Hallmark Christmas Cruise. They literally walked up to casting, said “Hey, pair us!” and it WORKED. It’s the most Hallmark-meets-real-life plot twist of 2025, and we love them even more now.
In Melt My Heart This Christmas, apparently those actors weren’t acting cold. Jennifer Wigmore confirmed the movie was shot in FEBRUARY. IN OTTAWA. Everyone on set was legitimately freezing. So yes, the chattering teeth were method.
Shop our Holiday Village Merch!
Shan from Sydney: Our New Favorite Long-Distance Best Friend
Shan stumbled upon our podcast and declared “I’ve found my people,” which is the highest compliment we can imagine. She’s laughing through Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper, crying through Christmas Above the Clouds, and lovingly declaring A Biltmore Christmas her all-time favorite – because Kristoffer Polaha is “swoon worthy,” and honestly? She’s not wrong.
The HR Nightmare at the Newport Museum: Jill Has Thoughts
Jill watched A Newport Christmas and immediately flagged several HR violations, including but not limited to: bosses dating employees, executives doing floral arrangements, and the suspicious absence of volunteers, vendors, or literally any event staff. Hallmark occasionally misses the workplace-logistics mark, and Jill is here to keep them honest.
Chantal’s Canadian Legal TV Corner – Must Watch
Chantal urges us to watch Family Law, describing it as “so good,” “accurate,” and full of Hallmark actors. It includes courtroom antics, sure, but also legitimate legal terminology that makes her Canadian, family-law-working heart sing. A wholehearted 10/10 recommendation from someone who knows her stuff.
Lisa Meets Jordan Belfi
Lisa casually drops “I met Jordan Belfi in Waikiki” like that’s a normal Tuesday, then points out something we should have caught: the early shaky-hand clue in A Keller Christmas Vacation clearly suggesting Parkinson’s. Also: she wants to know if we’re doing brackets this year, and yes, Lisa, we are emotionally preparing for the chaos as we speak.
Megan Notices the High School Musical Easter Egg (Because We All Missed It)
New-ish listener Megan caught a reference in A Keller Christmas Vacation that we COMPLETELY missed: Emory calling Cal “Coach Bolton” which is A High School Musical nod! This is why we need this community – so you can tell us what we completely blanked on during our note-taking frenzy.
Adam’s Simpsons Easter Egg Hunt
Adam points out a Simpsons reference in The More The Merrier – a town called North Haverbrook, straight out of the “Marge vs. the Monorail” episode. The crossover we didn’t expect.
We Could Not Love This Community More
Thank you for the corrections, the trivia, the personal stories, the international shoutouts, the HR accountability, and the pop-culture Easter eggs that keep us humble.
If you want to be featured in the next Listener Mailbag, send us your thoughts – long, short, chaotic, deeply researched – we’ll take it all.
Hallmark should honestly hire all of you.
More Hallmark Talk? Join Our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group
Join our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group! Tons of great people – just like you – who love Hallmark movies. We’re talking new movies, favorite movies, actors, Hallmark gossip, and so much more. Free to join, so click the link below or search “Girls Gone Hallmark” in Facebook Groups.
Don’t miss out on: Girls Gone Hallmark – A Group for Hallmark Movie Fans
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
