What We Know About Mistletoe Murders
Sarah Drew’s hit series Mistletoe Murders is making its Hallmark Channel debut after becoming a smash success on Hallmark+. The cozy crime drama captured audiences with its blend of small-town charm and holiday mystery, and now fans who missed it on streaming can catch all of Season 1 before Season 2 premieres on November 7. Here’s what to know about Mistletoe Murders and why this festive whodunit has become a must-watch for Hallmark mystery lovers.
This post has been updated on October 15, 2025.
Mistletoe Murders will make its Hallmark Channel network debut on Friday, October 17, 2025.
What is Mistletoe Murders About?
In Mistletoe Murders, Drew stars as Emily Lane, a character who is as complex as she is charming. Emily is described as smart, tough, and observant, with a dry sense of humor that adds a unique flavor to her persona. While she appears to be a perfectly lovely small-town shop owner, Emily harbors a secret past that could unravel her new life in Fletcher’s Grove if it ever came to light.
Emily’s day-to-day life revolves around running her quaint Christmas-themed store, which has become a beloved fixture in the community. However, when mysterious murders start occurring in the seemingly peaceful town, Emily’s curiosity and keen sense of justice drive her to investigate. With the help of a handsome local police detective and his savvy teen daughter, Emily dives into the world of crime-solving, all while trying to keep her past hidden.
Reviews for Mistletoe Murders
Girls Gone Hallmark reviewed season 1 of Mistletoe Murders during the summer of 2025, breaking down each two-episode mystery arc. Listen to all the reviews below.
- Mistletoe Murders Season 1 Episodes 1 & 2
- Mistletoe Murders Season 1 Episodes 3 & 4
- Mistletoe Murders Season 1 Episodes 5 & 6
Watch the Trailer for Mistletoe Murders
Watch the season 1 Mistletoe Murders trailer coming to Hallmark Channel for the 2025 Countdown to Christmas season.
Sarah Drew’s New Leading Role
Hallmark fans will recognize Sarah Drew from her standout roles in Branching Out and Guiding Emily. Beyond Hallmark, she’s best known for her many years playing Dr. April Kepner on Grey’s Anatomy.
Who is in Mistletoe Murders?
- Sarah Drew will play lead Emily Lane
- Peter Mooney (Retreat to You, Fly Away with Me) co-stars as Sam Wilner
- Lara Amersey (Operation Nutcracker) plays June Hubble
- Nicole Volossetski plays Nicki
- Isaac Kragten (Odd Squad) will portray Pete
- Arlene Duncan (Good Witch, Spinning Out) plays Vera Van Dorne
- Tom Cavanagh (Ed, The Flash)
- Jake Epstein (The Hardy Boys, The Umbrella Academy)
- David Hewlett (Stargate: Atlantis)
- Kylee Evans (Good Witch, Mistletoe Murders podcast series)
- Jean Yoon (Kim’s Convenience, Mistletoe Murders podcast series)
- Jeremy Durgana (A Time to Kill, See) appears as JD The Christmas DJ
- Sierra Marilyn Riley
- Steven Lund
Behind the Scenes: A Talented Team
Mistletoe Murders is brought to life by a talented team. The series is created by Ken Cuperus who is also responsible for creating and writing he popular Audible podcast of the same name.
Fans of Hallmark’s hit series The Way Home will be excited to know that award-winning director Grant Harvey is joining the team, bringing his expertise and vision to the project.
Will Mistletoe Murders Be on Hallmark?
Yes! Mistletoe Murders will officially air on Hallmark Channel following its smash success on Hallmark+. Season 1 makes its network debut starting October 17, airing over three consecutive weeks. Each week will feature back-to-back episodes, which is perfect since the series is structured in two-episode story arcs—each pair forming one complete mystery.
Then, mark your calendar for November 7, when Season 2 premieres on Hallmark Channel, following the same bingeable two-episode format. It’s the perfect chance to catch up—or rewatch—before the next round of holiday mysteries begins!
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
