Why February is the Perfect Time for a Hallmark Mystery
When you think of February, you probably imagine cliché red roses, chocolate hearts, and cheesy romantic movies, right? But why settle for sweet when you can stir in a little suspense? Hallmark Mysteries are here to save your February from being too predictable, bringing intrigue, twists, and captivating characters to balance out all that lovey-dovey fluff. So, forget the standard romance routine – here’s why February is the perfect time for a Hallmark Mystery, along with some top picks to keep you on the edge of your seat.

Why February Needs a Little Mystery
This month, shake things – because a little intrigue pairs perfectly with cozy vibes and, let’s be honest, makes for way more interesting viewing than yet another meet-cute. Here’s why these captivating whodunits deserve a spot on your watchlist.
- Balance the Romance – A Hallmark Mystery provides the perfect counterbalance to the endless meet-cutes and grand romantic gestures. They keep you guessing while still delivering that signature Hallmark charm.
- Cozy Vibes for Chilly Nights February is still winter in most places, making it the perfect time to snuggle under a blanket and play detective.
- Engaging Storylines Hallmark Mysteries offer more complex plots than your average rom-com, with compelling whodunits and clever clues.
Top Hallmark Mysteries to Watch This February
Ready to add some intrigue to your February? Here are our top picks for Hallmark Mysteries that will keep you guessing all month long.
Curious Caterer
Goldy Berry and Detective Tom Schultz from Curious Caterer serve up a deliciously slow-burn romance that’s as satisfying as one of Goldy’s catered desserts. Their crackling chemistry, witty banter, and knack for solving murders make this duo a must-watch for mystery fans who love a little tension with their sleuthing. Who knew catering and crime could pair so well?
With only five movies in the series (so far), you can easily binge these in a single weekend and still have time to dive into our next recommendation.

A Hannah Swensen Mystery
Hannah Swensen’s journey from Murder, She Baked to the revamped A Hannah Swensen Mystery is a buffet of cozy whodunits you’ll want to devour. From the original love triangle with Mike and Norman to the fresh energy Victor Webster brings to the table as Chad, there’s plenty of drama (and desserts) to chew through. And let’s be real – Barbara Niven as her glamorous, meddling mom Delores? Absolute cherry on top.
The mystery heats up with a brand-new installment in the series, Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery, dropping February 6th!

Mistletoe Murders
Hallmark+ brought the drama with Mistletoe Murders, a limited six-episode series that mixes holiday cheer with a side of deadly intrigue. Starring Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney, the story follows Emily as she juggles a Christmas scavenger hunt, a killer on the loose, and a past that won’t stay buried—oh, and Violet’s got surprises of her own for Sam! Fans are raving about this twisty, addictive series, and honestly, it’s worth the $7.99 for the month just to binge it.
And for all you Girls Gone Hallmark fans, mark your calendars because we’re diving into Mistletoe Murders with a full review this July 2025.

Crossword Mysteries
The Crossword Mysteries franchise starring Lacey Chabert and Brennan Elliott is a fan-favorite for good reason – these two seasoned pros have undeniable on-screen chemistry that’s pure Hallmark gold. With Tess Harper, a crossword editor turned amateur sleuth, piecing together murder mysteries and cracking art heist clues, it’s the perfect mix of brains, banter, and suspense.
Here’s another five-movie series you can easily squeeze into a weekend binge.

Mystery 101
Mystery 101 starring Kristoffer Polaha and Jill Wagner is the ultimate slow-burn mystery-romance fans adore – until they realized the series was left on a cliffhanger without a proper ending. Yep, it’s been years, and fans are still not over it. So, fair warning: if you dive in, prepare to join the collective outcry.
Good news, though – Girls Gone Hallmark is planning to recap the entire Mystery 101 series in summer 2025. Get ready for all the twists, chemistry, and maybe some commiserating about that infamous unresolved finale!

Signed, Sealed, Delivered
Signed, Sealed, Delivered isn’t your typical murder-and-intrigue mystery – it’s a heartwarming fan favorite that follows a team of quirky postal detectives solving the mysteries behind undeliverable letters. With its perfect blend of romance, humor, and heartfelt storytelling, it’s proof that sometimes the best mysteries are sealed with love, not crime!
Girls Gone Hallmark reviewed every single movie in this beloved franchise, and we’re sharing all the highlights of what we loved and learned along the way. This is truly a one-of-a-kind series!

This February, let Hallmark Mysteries add some intrigue to your evenings. Whether you’re solving crimes solo or hosting a mystery night with friends, these movies are sure to keep you on the edge of your seat – with plenty of heartwarming moments to remind you why you love Hallmark in the first place.
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!
