When Will the Two Newest Curious Caterer Movies Premiere in 2025?
If you’re anything like us, you’ve been eagerly awaiting your next serving of murder, mystery, and made-from-scratch mayhem from Hallmark’s Curious Caterer series. With Andrew Walker and Nikki DeLoach serving up chemistry that’s just as irresistible as Goldy’s gourmet dishes, it’s no wonder fans are craving more. But here’s the million-dollar mystery: when will the two newest Curious Caterer movies premiere in 2025?
Curious Caterer 2025 Movies: What We Know So Far
Curious Caterer: Tough Cookie and Curious Caterer: Prime Cut were both reported to be wrapped, but apparently we were led astray with that information! With titles, and we’re assuming scripts to go along with them, we can’t help but wonder what the hold up is.
When Will Curious Caterer: Tough Cookie and Prime Cut Premiere on Hallmark in 2025?
That’s the big question — and so far, Hallmark has stayed almost completely silent about the future of the Curious Caterer franchise. Despite reports that Tough Cookie and Prime Cut had already wrapped filming, it now seems that information may not have been accurate. Fans have been (patiently-ish) waiting for any real updates, but for now, we’re left wondering when — or even if — Hallmark Mystery will serve up more Curious Caterer in 2025.
Why Hallmark Fans Are Eagerly Awaiting the Curious Caterer 2025 Premiere Dates
The Curious Caterer series has become one of Hallmark’s most successful entries in the cozy mystery genre. Thanks to its charming blend of culinary intrigue, engaging whodunits, and the irresistible pairing of Nikki DeLoach and Andrew Walker, the films have developed a devoted fan following eager for each new installment.
It’s now been over six months since Curious Caterer: Forbidden Fruit premiered in October 2024. Historically, Hallmark has released new entries in the series during early spring and early fall – typically April and October. While many fans expected that pattern to continue in 2025, April is nearly behind us, and there’s still no word on what’s next.
The Future of Hallmark Mystery Movies
The future of Hallmark mysteries has become a hot topic among fans, with some speculating – and even fearing – that the network might eventually phase out its beloved mystery programming. It’s true that the pace of new franchise releases has slowed in 2025, fueling concern.
But let’s not sound the alarm just yet. In fact, Hallmark introduced a slew of new mystery titles since 2024, including The Cases of Mystery Lane, Nelly Knows Mysteries, Tipline Mysteries, Family Practice Mysteries, CrimeTime, True Justice, and Haunted Harmony Mysteries. Some of these premieres were met with major fanfare and solid ratings, proving there’s still plenty of appetite for clever whodunits and cozy crime-solving. So, are Hallmark mysteries really disappearing? Based on this lineup, it looks like they’re just getting started.
How Popular Is Curious Caterer? A Look at Hallmark Mystery Ratings
The numbers don’t lie – Curious Caterer: Forbidden Fruit was a standout performer for Hallmark Mystery in 2024. With a household audience of 566,000 and a total P2+ viewership of 683,000, it outpaced two other major franchises: A Hannah Swensen Mystery and The Jane Mysteries both of which drew lesser numbers (source). Despite Hallmark Mystery’s lighter 2025 mystery lineup, Curious Caterer continues to attract one of the largest and most loyal audiences, showing strong viewer retention and enthusiasm for Nikki DeLoach and Andrew Walker’s culinary crime-solving chemistry.
Curious Caterer Movie Premiere Predictions: Final Thoughts for Hallmark Mystery Fans
If you’re on the hunt for updates about when the new Curious Caterer movies will premiere, you’re definitely not alone. Whether you’re Team Tom & Goldy 4EVER, Team Give Mason Literally Anything to Do, Team Goldy: Please Stop Finding Dead Bodies, or just here for the cozy murder mysteries and clever kitchen clues, you’re among friends who totally get it.
So bookmark this page, follow Girls Gone Hallmark on social, and stay tuned. Because the moment Hallmark reveals a premiere date, we’ll be the first to spill the tea (and maybe a few cookie crumbs too).
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!
