Unscripted Shows on Hallmark+ Coming Soon!
Hallmark Channel, renowned for its heartwarming original movies, is stepping into new territory with the announcement of brand-new unscripted shows on Hallmark +. This bold move marks a significant expansion beyond their traditional scripted content, aiming to attract a broader audience while staying true to their feel-good brand. Let’s take a look at the new unscripted shows for Hallmark+.

Embracing Change: Hallmark’s Venture into Unscripted Shows
The decision to venture into unscripted programming reflects Hallmark’s strategic effort to diversify its offerings and engage viewers beyond holiday movies. These Hallmark unscripted shows promise to capture the essence of positivity, warmth, and genuine human connections —the hallmarks of Hallmark’s storytelling approach. They are calling the effort “Reality with Heart.”
A Varied Lineup of Unscripted Shows on Hallmark+
Hallmark+ will feature a variety of unscripted formats, ranging from lifestyle and home improvement shows to the network’s first reality competition show.
Finding Mr. Christmas
Synopsis: Ten aspiring actors will face a series of challenges vying for the title of “Mr. Christmas.” The ultimate prize: a starring role in one of this year’s “Countdown to Christmas” movies on Hallmark Channel. Created and hosted by Jonathan Bennett.
The incredibly funny and talented Melissa Peterman will be the head judge with a rotating cast of guest judges.
First impression: We’re crossing our fingers for a lineup of dreamy dudes to sleigh us all.
Celebrations With Lacey Chabert
Synopsis: Get ready to be swept off your feet with “Celebrations with Lacey Chabert”! Join Hallmark Channel favorite Lacey Chabert as she showers deserving individuals with the celebrations of their dreams, making hearts soar and smiles light up across the screen.
First impression: Lacey Chabert’s out here like ‘You get a party! And you get a party! Everybody gets a party!’
Ready, set, glow
Synopsis: Actor Wes Brown takes viewers on a nationwide journey to witness dazzling, festive displays and the heartfelt stories behind them.
First impression: This show sounds similar to ABC’s “The Great Christmas Light Fight” — here’s hoping for more heart and less synchronized Christmas lights.
small town set up
Synopsis: Ashley Williams embarks on a journey through small-town communities, uniting neighbors in their search for true love and crafting heartwarming Hallmark romance in the network’s inaugural reality dating show.
First impression: Just like our Hallmark movies, we’re eagerly anticipating some mid-life, second chance romances.
home is where the heart is
Synopsis: Luke Macfarlane takes the reins as producer and host of the new renovation show to debut in 2025.
First impression: This is giving us major “move that bus!” vibes and we’re here for it.
Expanding Reach: Hallmark’s Move into Reality TV Shows
For Hallmark, known primarily for its scripted dramas and romantic comedies, this step into unscripted programming represents a calculated risk to expand its audience base. By introducing these new shows, Hallmark aims to appeal to viewers who enjoy reality programming that aligns with the network’s heartfelt ethos.
The move into unscripted shows also reflects broader industry trends, where streaming platforms are increasingly diversifying their content to cater to varied viewer preferences. Hallmark’s decision to launch Hallmark+ and feature exclusive Hallmark reality TV shows underscores its commitment to evolving with changing viewer habits and preferences in the digital age.
Stay tuned for updates as Hallmark continues to unveil more details about their exciting lineup of unscripted shows for Hallmark+, promising to bring joy, positivity, and meaningful stories to audiences worldwide.
Which unscripted show on Hallmark+ are you looking forward to most?
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!

2 Comments
Comments are closed.