True Justice: Eye For An Eye
The Justice Warriors are officially back, and we’ve been ready. After what felt like a very long wait between installments, True Justice: Eye For An Eye drops this crew straight into the deeply terrifying world of school politics, parent coalitions, and competitive mom energy – which somehow might be more dangerous than actual criminals. his second installment in the budding Hallmark Mystery franchise once again centers Katherine McNamara and Markian Tarasiuk alongside the rest of the Justice Warriors team as they work to clear a mother accused of murdering another member of the Parent School Coalition, while Nikki DeLoach and Benjamin Ayres return in supporting roles. If the first movie established anything, it’s that this franchise is leaning fully into its fast-paced, team-driven mystery format – and it continues to be a fun fit for the Hallmark Mystery lineup.
True Justice: An Eye For An Eye will premiere on Saturday, May 23, 2026, on Hallmark Channel (and will be available to stream on Hallmark+ the following day). Learn more about how to get Hallmark+ for free with a library card.
The Girls Gone Hallmark Listener Mailbag is officially OPEN! We want to hear from YOU – spill your thoughts, hot takes, and favorite moments from this movie! Email us at hello@girlsgonehallmark.com or leave a voice message at 949-329-8090 and you just might be featured in an upcoming episode!
How Many Movies are in the True Justice Franchise on Hallmark?
With the premiere of True Justice: Eye For An Eye on May 23, 2026, Hallmark Mystery’s True Justice franchise officially expands to two movies. The series first debuted with True Justice: Family Ties in 2024, introducing viewers to the Justice Warriors team led by Katherine McNamara. A third installment, True Justice: Lost Love, has already been announced, though Hallmark has not yet confirmed a release date.
Listen to Girls Gone Hallmark’s Review of True Justice: Eye For An Eye
The Cast of True Justice: Eye For An Eye
- Katherine McNamara returns as Casey, marking her first return to Hallmark Channel since the debut installment of the True Justice mystery franchise.
- Markian Tarasiuk returns as Eli. Most recently, Hallmark fans saw him in Nelly Knows Mysteries: All Manners of Murder.
- Marisa McIntyre returns as Sarah marking her third project for Hallmark.
- Alexander Nunez returns as private investigator Liam. Prior to Hallmark, viewers may recognize him from a recent role in Memory of a Killer.
- Nikki DeLoach co-stars as Professor Ambrose. Nikki will star in the forthcoming The Greek Aisle.
- Benjamin Ayres co-stars as D.A. Quinn. Hallmark fans recently saw Ayres in the first season of Hope Valley: 1874 on Hallmark+.
Who Wrote True Justice: Eye For An Eye?
Hallmark fan favorite Nikki DeLoach shares screenplay credit for True Justice: Eye For An Eye alongside writing partner Megan McNulty. This marks DeLoach’s fifth writing credit, with the duo also penning the forthcoming third installment in the True Justice franchise.
This installment also brings in a new director, with Lisa Soper stepping behind the camera for Eye For An Eye. Her previous credits include Riverdale, Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin, and most recently, several episodes of Ripple.
More Hallmark Talk? Join Our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group
Join our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group! Tons of great people – just like you – who love Hallmark movies. We’re talking new movies, favorite movies, actors, Hallmark gossip, and so much more. Free to join, so click the link below or search “Girls Gone Hallmark” in Facebook Groups.
Don’t miss out on: Girls Gone Hallmark – A Group for Hallmark Movie Fans
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
