Top 12 Must-Watch Fall Movies on Hallmark Channel
As the leaves change color and the air turns crisp, there’s no better way to embrace the cozy season than with Hallmark Channel’s lineup of heartwarming fall movies. Grab a blanket, a warm drink, and settle in for these top 12 must-watch fall films on Hallmark that capture the essence of autumn and the spirit of love and romance.

1. “Pumpkin Pie Wars” – 2016

In this delightful rom-com, rival bakery owners Casey and Sam are pitted against each other in a pumpkin pie contest. Sparks fly as they compete, but the real magic happens as they discover their true feelings for one another. Stars Julie Gonzalo as Casey and Eric Aragon as Sam. The script was written by Nina Weinman and it was directed by Steven R. Monroe.
Listen to the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast review of “Pumpkin Pie Wars”
2. “Harvest Moon” – 2015
When her family’s business faces financial ruin, a spoiled city girl is forced to move to a pumpkin farm owned by her late father. There, she learns valuable life lessons and finds unexpected love. Stars Jessy Schram as Jenny and Jesse Hutch as Brett. The script was written by J.P. Martin and Ron Oliver, while the movie was directed by Peter DeLuise.
3. “Autumn Dreams” – 2015

Years after their impromptu teenage marriage is annulled, Annie and Ben are brought back together by a legal glitch. As they navigate the fallout, they rekindle their old romance amidst the picturesque fall scenery. Stars Jill Wagner as Annie and Colin Egglesfield as Ben. The script was written by Laurie Stevens and directed by Neill Fearnley.
4. “Falling for Vermont” – 2017

A best-selling author escapes her demanding life and ends up in a small Vermont town with no memory of who she is. As she starts anew, she finds peace and love with the local doctor. Stars Julie Gonzalo as Angela and Benjamin Ayres as Jeff. The script was written by Jay Baxter, Shaun Zaken, and Michael G. Larkin. The movie was directed by David Winning.
5. “Love, Fall & Order” – 2019

When a woman returns to her hometown to help her father with his legal battle over a pumpkin farm, she reunites with her high school rival. Their competitive past gives way to a new, unexpected romance. This one stars Erin Cahill as Claire, Gregory Harrison as Hank, and former Hallmark actor Trevor Donovan as Patrick. The script was written by Audrey Shulman and directed by Claire Niederpruem,
6. “All of My Heart: Inn Love” – 2017
Brian and Jenny are in the midst of renovating their dream inn when fall arrives. The couple faces various challenges, but the beauty of autumn and their growing love help them overcome every obstacle. Stars Lacey Chabert as Jenny and Brennan Elliott as Brian. The script was written by Karen Berger and the movie was directed by prolific Hallmark director Terry Ingram.
7. “Under the Autumn Moon” – 2018

Alex, a big-city executive, travels to a dude ranch to close a business deal but ends up finding love and a new perspective on life. The stunning fall landscape serves as the perfect backdrop for this heartwarming story. Stars Wes Brown as Josh and Lindy Booth as Alex. The script was written by Nicole Avril, Tracy Andreen, and Edgar Lyall, while the movie was directed by Gary Yates.
8. “October Kiss” – 2015

Poppy, a free-spirited woman, takes a temporary nanny job for a widowed father of two. As Halloween approaches, she helps the family heal and discovers that love can be found in the most unexpected places. Ashely Williams stars as Poppy and Sam Jaeger as Ryan. The script was written by MacKenzie Austin and the movie was directed by Lynne Stopkewich.
Listen to what Girls Gone Hallmark thought about “October Kiss”
9. “Autumn in the Vineyard” – 2016

Former high school sweethearts Frankie and Nate inherit a vineyard and are forced to work together. Amidst the beautiful fall harvest, they rediscover their old love and build a future together. Rachel Leigh Cooks plays Frankie and Brendan Penny plays Nate. The script was written by writers Marina Adair and Suzette Couture, while the movie was directed by Scott Smith.
“Autumn in the Vineyard” review from Girls Gone Hallmark
10. “Good Witch: Curse From a Rose” – 2019
Cassie Nightingale, Middleton’s favorite enchantress, is back in this magical fall-themed installment. When an old friend visits with intentions to settle a score, Cassie must rely on her family and friends to protect her town and maintain the harmony of autumn. Stars Catherine Bell and James Denton.
11. “Roadhouse Romance” – 2021

Country music fan Callie returns home and meets a director named Luke who’s visiting town. As they work together to revive her family’s BBQ restaurant, they find themselves falling in love amidst the charming fall backdrop. Tyler Hynes stars as Luke while country-singer Lauren Alaina plays Callie. The script was written by Sally Robinson and the movie was directed by Paul Miller.
Girls Gone Hallmark gives high praise for Roadhouse Romance – Listen Here
12. “Love at the Thanksgiving Day Parade” – 2012
An enthusiastic Thanksgiving parade coordinator is taken aback when a wealthy consultant is brought in to evaluate the parade’s finances. As she tries to show him that the parade holds a deeper meaning beyond just money, she unexpectedly begins to fall for him. Written by Nancy Silvers and Bill Froehlich and masterfully directed by Ron Oliver, this heartwarming story features Autumn Reeser in one of her best Hallmark roles, alongside a very sexy Antonio Cupo.
Girls Gone Hallmark Welcomes Deck the Hallmark to review “Love at the Thanksgiving Day Parade”
The Shift from Fall to Christmas
In recent years, Hallmark Channel has significantly reduced its fall movie offerings to make room for the extensive Countdown to Christmas lineup. While Christmas movies bring joy and festivity, we mustn’t forget that fall is a beloved season for many viewers who cherish its unique charm and themes. The rich hues of autumn, the coziness of pumpkin patches, and the warmth of harvest celebrations are elements that many fans still yearn to see reflected in Hallmark’s programming.

We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!
