Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story Review & Cast
Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story premiered Saturday, October 17 on Hallmark Channel and is streaming now on Hallmark+. Three movies in, this one came out swinging on opening weekend, and it gave us Marsha Mason, Malört shots and the best hair we have ever seen in a Hallmark movie. Our full review is below, along with the complete cast and every Chicago Bears cameo.
Our ratings: Wendy gave it 4 stars, Megan gave it 4.25.
It aired on night two of Hallmark Channel’s 17th annual Countdown to Christmas, right after the season opener ‘Tis the Season for Setups. That is the earliest a Holiday Touchdown movie has ever premiered. The Chiefs movie aired in late November 2024 and the Bills movie on November 22, 2025, so moving the Bears film to opening weekend was a real vote of confidence in the franchise.
Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story premiered Saturday, October 17, 2026 at 8:00 pm ET/PT on Hallmark Channel. It is streaming now on Hallmark+ and will re-air throughout the Countdown to Christmas season.

Listen to Girls Gone Hallmark’s Review of Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story
Avery Clark is a freelance reporter home in Chicago for Christmas who lands a story about a Bears superfan attending her 500th game. The catch is that she knows nothing about football (she’s football neutral, “Switzerland, baby!”) so the superfan’s firefighter grandson becomes her guide to Bears Nation.
If you have been following along with us since the beginning, you know this franchise holds a special place in our hearts. We reviewed Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story when it premiered in 2024 and Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story when it premiered in 2025. Three for three now, and we have thoughts about all of them.
The movie filmed entirely on location in and around Chicago through June and July, showcasing iconic locations, beloved traditions, and the passionate fan base that surrounds one of the NFL’s most storied franchises. Which, as several Chicagoans have since pointed out to us, is exactly why the June shoot shows in a few places.
Dustin Rikert directs (Lost in Paradise, A Newport Christmas), with a teleplay by Christine Garver, Stephanie Jackson, and Marcy Holland (The Christmas Quest, My Dreams of You), based on a story by Garver and Jackson.
Costume design is by Keith Nielsen, who has now worked on all three Holiday Touchdown movies. That makes him more of a constant in this franchise than either the director or the writing team. Hair and makeup design is credited to Jessica Scheithoot and Avery Rasmussen, and we are going to have a lot to say about that further down.
View the full Countdown to Christmas 2026 Lineup!
Our Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story Review
Megan’s first impression was simply: justice for the architectural boat tour. Wendy’s was that she is no longer joining Bears Nation, she is joining Italian Beef Nation. We will get to both.
What We Loved
Marsha Mason, Marsha Mason, Marsha Mason. She is the heart of this movie and she carries every scene she’s in. The flashback with her husband after her diagnosis, the moment alone outside the stadium after the game, her trio of besties. Megan went in not especially familiar with her work and came out a convert.
Lyndsy Fonseca and Robert Buckley are a terrific pairing. Both of them have comedy in their acting bones, and they have real chemistry. We could not have asked for two better leads in these roles.
The hair. Megan would like it on the record that Lyndsy Fonseca has the best hair she has ever seen in a Hallmark movie. Down and wavy, blown out for the gown, half up, ponytail, a bun, and a braided style so good she spent the scene trying to reverse-engineer it. Also the green glasses, which Megan would like to buy, if anyone knows.
The opening scene. Grandma and Grandpa meeting outside Soldier Field, shot and costumed to look genuinely of its era, all browns and muted tones before the movie snaps into present-day blues and oranges. And at the Bears Care gala, Avery’s deep blue gown with the orange clutch is a Bears palette without being a costume. (Friend of the show costume designer Keith Nielsen really knows what he’s doing!)

Avery, Jody and Ron. Avery struggling to find her place in her mother’s new life is handled with real care, and she never tips into resentment about it. Then they lighten the whole thing by making her a cornhole savant who wins the bags tournament with her stepdad. The personalized cornhole bags she gives him later are adorable.

No third act misunderstanding! No manufactured fight between the leads. The crisis is “where is Darlene,” which we also found funny, because that tailgate had been going a while before anybody thought to ask.
And the ending treats them like adults. Matt’s position is that there is FaceTime, there are phone calls, there are airplanes, and he is not letting her go over logistics. Let’s make a habit of this level of adult behavior.
Our Wishes
More comedy. This was the big one for both of us. The script leans on warmth rather than jokes, which is a fair choice and well executed. But Robert Buckley is one of the funniest people Hallmark has, and watching him in Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper or An Unexpected Valentine tells you what he can do when a script lets him run. Here he is landing the handful of comic beats he’s given and you can feel how many more he had in him.
Wendy wanted more romantic tension. The scarf-wrapping scene, where Matt wraps a scarf around Avery and they almost kiss before getting interrupted, is a taste of what these two can do. She wanted more of that. Megan’s pick was the dance at the Christmas market, which Wendy says did not register for her at all.
Wendy’s bigger wish is structural. Strip away the Bears, the Chicago of it all and the football traditions, and underneath is a very familiar Hallmark shape: ambitious woman goes home, meets a handsome local, questions her career, finds a reason to stay. The setting was unique, the story was not. She also went in expecting a magical element the way the Bills movie had one, and spent a good while convinced Darlene was Mrs. Claus.
Megan does not mind the formula when it is done well. We don’t always agree!
Did You See That?
- Malört shots. We have never seen anyone take a shot in a Hallmark movie. Matt calls it a Chicago tradition, and Chicagoans have since confirmed to us that it is both a staple and famously, deliberately awful.
- That Italian beef was far too dry. Avery’s mom even says she’ll take it double dipped. It was not dipped. Commenters on Instagram agreed!
- The thermostat reads 75 degrees in a Chicago winter. Filmed in June, and it shows.
- The Always product placement. Gran’s neighbor arrives with groceries and the box is not discreetly sticking out of the bag, then gets its own shot in the front of frame.
- Avery reads the karaoke screen for the words to Deck the Halls. Every four-year-old knows those words.
- September 19, 1985 turns up in Avery’s story. A real date in Bears history, and also Megan’s sixth birthday.
- “One Day at a Time” engraved on the Bears album. We both assumed it meant something else entirely before the real meaning was revealed.
- Santa is the same Santa. Abraham Benrubi has played him in all three Holiday Touchdown movies, and this time he didn’t even make the magic happen. He was just their Santa.
- Hallmark ornaments on screen, which came with a QR code on the bottom of the live broadcast. Interactive television has arrived.
The Movie Marquee Easter Egg
In the opening credits, a movie marquee shows Next Stop Christmas, which stars Lyndsy Fonseca and was also directed by Dustin Rikert, and The Christmas House, which Robert Buckley starred in and wrote. One title for each lead, hidden in the first ninety seconds.
That’s three for three on this Holiday Touchdown tradition. The Chiefs movie put three titles on a marquee behind Derek and Alana: A Holiday Spectacular for the writer, An Unexpected Christmas for Tyler Hynes and The Santa Summit for Hunter King. The Bills movie put up one, Five Gold Rings, and left it there so long we complained about it on the podcast. This year there are two. Someone is listening.
Both the Chiefs marquee and this one were caught by Mackie, our social media manager, who has now spotted this Easter egg two franchise installments apart.
How We Rated It
| Movie | Wendy | Megan |
|---|---|---|
| A Chiefs Love Story (2024) | 3.25 | 3.75 |
| A Bills Love Story (2025) | 4.25 | 4.5 |
| A Bears Love Story (2026) | 4 | 4.25 |
A slight step back from the Bills for both of us, and still a strong score. Megan has now rated every one of these a quarter star above Wendy, which is becoming a bit.
The Mike Ditka Tribute
The movie includes a tribute to Mike Ditka, with his photo and his seat marked. Given the timing, it was almost certainly filmed and locked long before it aired, which makes it land differently than anyone involved could have planned.
Which NFL Team Should Hallmark Do Next?
We are assuming there will be a fourth. Last year we got a flood of emails for Baltimore. Wendy is lobbying hard for a West Coast team, entirely so the two of us can turn up as extras, and would happily settle for Denver or Arizona.
Tell us who you want. Email hello@girlsgonehallmark.com.
Who Stars in Holiday Touchdown: A Bears Love Story?
Lyndsy Fonseca (How I Met Your Mother, Single on the 25th) stars as Avery opposite Robert Buckley (One Tree Hill, Chesapeake Shores) as Matt.

Rounding out the main cast:
- Marsha Mason as Darlene — a four-time Academy Award nominee for The Goodbye Girl, Cinderella Liberty, Chapter Two and Only When I Laugh, and beloved from Frasier and Grace and Frankie
- Barbara Alyn Woods as Jody (One Tree Hill, Honey, I Shrunk the Kids)
- Khary Payton as Ron (The Walking Dead, Young Justice)

If you’re getting a very specific feeling about that cast list — yes. Robert Buckley and Barbara Alyn Woods are both One Tree Hill alums, which makes this an unexpected Tree Hill reunion inside a Bears Christmas movie. We did not have that on our 2026 bingo card.

Dustin Rikert directs (Lost in Paradise, A Newport Christmas), with a teleplay by Christine Garver, Stephanie Jackson, and Marcy Holland (The Christmas Quest, My Dreams of You), based on a story by Garver and Jackson.

Which Chicago Bears Players Appear in the Hallmark Movie?
This is where the Holiday Touchdown franchise always delivers, and the Chicago Bears roster is deep:
Chicago Bears Players and Coaching Staff:
- Head Coach Ben Johnson
- Tight end Colston Loveland
- Tight end Cole Kmet
- Quaterback Caleb Williams

Chicago Bears Legends and Special Guests
- Mike Singletary – Former linebacker and Pro Football Hall of Famer
- Charles “Peanut” Tillman – Former cornerback
- Dan Hampton – Former defensive lineman and Pro Football Hall of Famer
- Connie Payton – Wife of the late Walter Payton, legendary Bears running back and Pro Football Hall of Famer
- Staley Da Bear, The Chicago Bears’ beloved official mascot

Familiar Hallmark Stars Make Cameo Appearances
A couple of familiar Hallmark faces join the fun! Tamera Mowry-Housley, known for Haunted Harmony Mysteries and the upcoming Mistletoe and Mimosas, makes an appearance alongside Marilu Henner, a fan favorite from the Aurora Teagarden Mysteries franchise.


Two Chicago Bears Fans Win Walk-On Roles Through Bears Care Charity Auction
Bears Care, the team’s charitable arm, partnered with Hallmark Channel to auction off two walk-on roles benefiting the Chicagoland community. Winners Carrie May-Borich and Phillip Salamone make their on-screen debuts alongside longtime Bears season ticket holders and Hallmark fans Julia and Ken Wegner.
Four lucky fans now have the ultimate Christmas bragging rights: “That’s me in the Hallmark movie!”
There’s a Chicago Bears Hallmark Ornament

Hallmark is releasing a Chicago Bears Santa ornament alongside the movie. It is available now on Hallmark.com and at regional Hallmark Gold Crown stores.
If the Chiefs and Bills ornaments are any indication, these sell quickly in local markets, so Bears fans will want to snag one while they can!
Everything to Know About the Chicago Bears Hallmark Movie
The movie filmed entirely on location in and around Chicago, showcasing iconic locations, beloved traditions, and the passionate fan base that surrounds one of the NFL’s most storied franchises. Eagle-eyed fans caught the crew filming around the Windy City through June and July, and production officially wrapped last month.
Skydance Sports is back as executive producer, continuing the partnership that made the first two movies possible. They are the team behind the production company that previously worked with Hallmark and the NFL on the Kansas City Chiefs and Buffalo Bills installments, so this is a familiar and proven collaboration.
The announcement was made in a fun way too: Chicago Bears Head Coach Ben Johnson and Tight End Colston Loveland appeared in a video to break the news, which is very much in the spirit of how Hallmark has handled these reveals from the start.
What Makes the Chicago Bears Hallmark Movie Special?
The Chiefs gave us Kansas City romance and Taylor Swift-era football fever. The Bills gave us Bills Mafia heart and Buffalo traditions. The Bears bring something different: a century-old NFL franchise, a passionate national fan base, and a team deeply woven into Chicago’s identity. According to Hallmark, the movie celebrates the traditions, spirit, and love that connect Bears fans to their team and city, especially during the holiday season. That’s exactly what this franchise does best.
The Success Behind Hallmark’s Holiday Touchdown Franchise
There’s a reason Hallmark keeps bringing football and Christmas together. Both previous Holiday Touchdown movies ranked among the year’s most-watched cable movies. The Chiefs movie became a cultural moment, and the Bills proved the formula wasn’t just a one-time success. Now it’s Chicago’s turn, and Hallmark is clearly onto something with this franchise.
- Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story
- Everything We Know About Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story
- Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story Review
We’re Your New Hallmark Besties
Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!
Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!
