Get Ready for Finding Mr. Christmas: Hallmark’s First-Ever Reality Competition Show!

Hallmark+ is rolling out its first-ever reality competition series, and it’s bound to be a festive sensation! Finding Mr. Christmas is set to dazzle audiences with a unique blend of holiday cheer and reality TV excitement. Here’s everything you need to know about this brand-new show, which promises to be a delightful addition to Hallmark’s holiday lineup. Updated October 23, 2024.

Get ready for Finding Mr. Christmas on Hallmark+! Discover the show’s concept, host Jonathan Bennett, and why it’s the must-watch reality competition this fall.

When Does Finding Mr. Christmas Premiere?

Finding Mr. Christmas will kick off with two episodes on October 31, 2024 exclusively on Hallmark+. New episodes will drop on Thursdays only on Hallmark+.

What to Expect

Finding Mr. Christmas is more than just a reality competition; it’s a celebration of all things holiday. The series will feature a mix of fun challenges, heartfelt moments, and plenty of holiday spirit. As the contestants vie for the title of “Mr. Christmas,” viewers will get a front-row seat to their journeys, watching as they navigate the highs and lows of the competition.

The winner will not only earn the title of “Mr. Christmas” but also will land a leading role in a 2024 Hallmark Channel holiday movie called Happy Howlidays co-starring Jessica Lowndes and premiering on Saturday, December 21st.

The Concept: A Quest for a New Hallmark Leading Man

Finding Mr. Christmas brings ten charming and charismatic contestants into the spotlight, where they’ll compete in a series of challenges designed to test their acting chops and festive spirit.

Who are the Guys Competing for Mr. Christmas on Hallmark+

Entertainment Weekly was the first to reveal the ten hunks competing for the title of Mr. Christmas. Let’s check out who they are!

  • Blake Kelley – A 36-year-old sales manager from Beaumont, Texas. With his Southern charm and business acumen, Blake might just be the smoothest talker in the competition.
  • Daxton Bloomquist – A 36-year-old actor from Los Angeles, California. Broadway star alert! Daxton has graced the stage in The Book of Mormon—he’s the most theatrical contender.
  • David Habashy – A 29-year-old aerospace engineer from Vancouver, British Columbia. David is the brainiac of the bunch, ready to launch himself into Mr. Christmas glory.
  • Elijah Malcomb – A 31-year-old theater actor and delivery driver from Lodi, New Jersey. After touring with Hamilton for five years, Elijah brings the dramatic flair and heart to this competition.
  • Ezra Moreland – A 31-year-old model from San Diego, California. Former Navy rescue diver turned model, Ezra is the hero of the group, with both looks and bravery on his side.
  • Gage Robinson – A 29-year-old marketing consultant from Los Angeles, California. Gage knows how to sell himself—he’s the most strategic of the bunch, with a flair for getting noticed.
  • Hayden Maher – A 30-year-old children’s entertainer from Los Angeles, California. The most fun-loving of the contestants, Hayden is sure to bring joy and laughter with his playful spirit.
  • Isaac Ramirez – A 28-year-old firefighter from Santa Clarita, California. The real-life hero, Isaac brings courage, heart, and smoldering good looks to the competition.
  • Jonathan Wells – A 27-year-old entrepreneur and former track and field star from Chicago, Illinois. Jonathan is the athlete of the group, with speed and determination that could sprint him to the top.
  • Parker Gregory – A 39-year-old model from League City, Texas. The most experienced of the pack, Parker is a seasoned pro with killer looks and a Texas swagger.

Host and Co-Creator: Jonathan Bennett

The show is hosted by Jonathan Bennett, known for his iconic role in Mean Girls and his impressive Hallmark Channel filmography, including the upcoming The Groomsmen trilogy, The Holiday Sitter and the upcoming Cherry Lane trilogy sequel.

Bennett brings his extensive experience and infectious enthusiasm to Finding Mr. Christmas, promising to infuse the show with the perfect blend of fun and holiday magic. Not only is he the host, but Bennett is also a co-creator of the show, ensuring that it reflects the spirit and charm that Hallmark fans love.

Judging Panel: Star Power and Expertise

Joining Bennett as a judge is the delightful Melissa Peterman, known for her roles in Reba and Haul Out the Holly. Peterman’s keen eye for talent and her own experience in Hallmark films make her a perfect fit for the judging panel.

Throughout the season, viewers can also look forward to guest appearances by several Hallmark Channel stars who will serve as guest judges, including Nikki DeLoach, Tyler Hynes, Brooke D’Orsay, Rachel Boston, Ali Liebert, B.J. Britt, and Erin Cahill. In addition to these Hallmark favorites, judges Witney Carson and Keltie Knight will also join from outside the Hallmark world.

(Photo by Phillip Faraone/Getty Images for Hallmark Media)

Filming Location: A Festive Ranch in Utah

The show is filmed on a stunning ranch in Utah, which has been decked out in the most festive holiday decorations. This picturesque setting provides the perfect backdrop for the competition, combining rustic charm with holiday sparkle. The ranch’s decorations and scenic views are sure to add to the show’s festive atmosphere and make it a visual treat for viewers.

We’re Your New Hallmark Besties

Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!

Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!

Exclusively on the Girls Gone Hallmark podcast. Subscribe today!

About Megan and Wendy

Similar Posts