Change of Heart: Sam Jaeger and Ariel Winter Are Making a Hallmark+ Series

Last updated: October 13, 2026

Hallmark announced the cast of Change of Heart today, and we have thoughts, mostly about who’s producing it.

It’s a six-episode series coming to Hallmark+ in 2027. Sam Jaeger and Ariel Winter star, with Rachel Boston, Julie Gonzalo and Kevin Vidal alongside them. Filming started back in September, so this has been in the works a while without any of us knowing.

Here’s everything Hallmark has said so far, plus something in the announcement that piqued our interest.

Change of Heart coming to Hallmark Plus starring Dan Jaeger and Ariel Winter

What Is Change of Heart About?

Sam Jaeger plays Charlie Wyatt, a divorce attorney who wins at any cost. Then he gets a heart transplant, and afterward he starts pushing people back toward each other. Which, for a man who has spent twenty years taking families apart for a living, is quite a turn.

Ariel Winter plays his younger sister Brit, who ends up his partner in all the matchmaking.

We love this setup. Hallmark has given us a lot of matchmakers over the years, and they’re usually the town sweetheart or somebody’s meddling grandmother. A burned-out divorce lawyer is new, and the comedy writes itself.

Change of Heart Cast

  • Sam Jaeger as Charlie Wyatt. You know him from Parenthood and The Handmaid’s Tale. Hallmark people know him from October Kiss.
  • Ariel Winter as Brit. Eleven seasons as Alex Dunphy on Modern Family, and the voice of Sofia the First.
  • Rachel Boston. One of Hallmark’s greats, most recently in The More the Merrier, and before that Adventures in Love and Birding. She’ll co-star in Return to Santa this Countdown to Christmas season.
  • Julie Gonzalo. Another Hallmark mainstay. We just saw her in A Knight to Remember and last year in My Argentine Heart.
  • Kevin Vidal. Workin’ Moms, Culprits, and the Canadian premiere cast of Come From Away.

Hallmark hasn’t told us who Rachel Boston, Julie Gonzalo and Kevin Vidal are playing. We’ll add character names here as soon as they do.

When Does Change of Heart Premiere on Hallmark+?

Sometime in 2027. That’s all we’ve got. No month, no season, no date.

What we do know: six episodes in season one, filming started September 2026, and it streams exclusively on Hallmark+. Going by how Hope Valley: 1874 and Paris Is Always a Good Idea rolled out, we’d bet on weekly episodes rather than everything dropping at once.

Okay, Let’s Talk About The Way Home Connection

Change of Heart is produced by FOX Entertainment Studios. And in the announcement, FOX’s head of scripted made no secret of the fact they’re building on the success of The Way Home.

If you’ve been with us a while, you know what The Way Home means around here. Our coverage of that show is the most listened-to thing we have ever made, by a wide margin, and we are not over it.

That show also proved that Hallmark break free from the mold a little bit, while still playing within the same boundaries that its audience has come to expect.

We were all in on The Way Home, and we’ll definitely be marking our calendars as soon as premiere date is announced for Change of Heart.

For the record: Jonny Umansky created the series, Erin Gibson of The Chicken Sisters is showrunning, and Keshet Studios developed it over several years and produces alongside FOX.

What This Says About Hallmark+

Hope Valley: 1874 is the one that got us. We figured we’d be slogging through those reviews and now they’re something we look forward to, which we should have seen coming with Bethany Joy Lenz and Benjamin Ayres carrying it.

Paris Is Always a Good Idea we loved outright, and we can’t pretend that one shocked us. Hand Lacey Chabert a series and she’s going to deliver.

Hallmark+ got off to a rocky start but it seems to have found its footing with original programming and we’re really looking forward to what’s next.

Change of Heart FAQ

Who stars in Change of Heart?

Sam Jaeger and Ariel Winter lead as Charlie and Brit Wyatt. Rachel Boston, Julie Gonzalo and Kevin Vidal are also series regulars.

How many episodes is Change of Heart?

Six, in the first season.

Where can I watch Change of Heart?

Hallmark+ only. It isn’t airing on Hallmark Channel.

Is Change of Heart related to The Way Home?

Not story-wise. They share a studio. Both come from FOX Entertainment Studios in partnership with Hallmark, and FOX pointed straight at The Way Home when they announced this one.

Has Sam Jaeger been in a Hallmark movie before?

He has. October Kiss, which is one of the few Hallmark movies set at Halloween. We ran through that very short list in our Spirit of Halloween episode.

When did Change of Heart start filming?

September 2026.

More Hallmark+ From Us

More Hallmark Talk? Join Our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group

Looking for a Hallmark-centric Facebook group with no drama? Check out the Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group and join today!

Join our Girls Gone Hallmark Facebook Group! Tons of great people – just like you – who love Hallmark movies. We’re talking new movies, favorite movies, actors, Hallmark gossip, and so much more. Free to join, so click the link below or search “Girls Gone Hallmark” in Facebook Groups.

Don’t miss out on: Girls Gone Hallmark – A Group for Hallmark Movie Fans

We’re Your New Hallmark Besties

Hey there! We’re Girls Gone Hallmark! Megan’s a longtime Hallmark movie fan, while Wendy – well, she used to be a Hallmark hater. Now, we’ve teamed up to share our (often very different!) takes on these films. Get ready for some lively, fun-filled conversations!

Check out the library of Hallmark movies we’ve reviewed!

Subscribe today!

’

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *